A three-bedroom, one-bath ranch at 6 Central Avenue in Demarest went on the market July 12, 2026, at $750,000. It closed September 11 for $900,000. Earlier that year, two six-bedroom Colonials at 3 and 7 Central Avenue each sold for about $3.4 million. Both closed below their asking prices.
That is one street and one year, and the pattern runs against the usual assumption. The house at the low end drew the competition. The houses at the high end left room to negotiate. For anyone weighing an original Demarest home against a finished new build, the Central Avenue sales show where the pressure actually sat in 2026.
Three Sales on One Street
These three 2026 Central Avenue sales, as recorded on the New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, sit at the two ends of the street's price range.
| Address | Style | Bedrooms / Full Baths | Asking Price | Sale Price | Sale Date | Sale as Share of Asking |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Central Avenue | Colonial | 6 / 6 | $3,499,000 | $3,450,000 | May 21, 2026 | 98.6% |
| 7 Central Avenue | Colonial | 6 / 6 | $3,699,888 | $3,435,000 | July 3, 2026 | 92.8% |
| 6 Central Avenue | Ranch | 3 / 1 | $750,000 | $900,000 | Sept. 11, 2026 | 120% |
Borough planning records confirm that 3 Central Avenue was newly built. A building permit was issued May 15, 2025, and the certificate of occupancy came May 11, 2026. The listing for 7 Central Avenue does not give a build year, so treat it as a comparable six-bedroom sale on the same block rather than a confirmed new build.
Between them, a four-bedroom, four-bath ranch at 19 Central Avenue sold July 1, 2026, for $1,465,000. The difference between the ranch at number 6 and the new build at number 3 is $2,550,000, and the two sales were negotiated under very different conditions.
Where the Bidding Happened
Across Bergen County, single-family homes that closed in October 2026 sold for 102.0% of list price on average. From January through October 2026, the figure was 103.8%, according to the NJ REALTORS October 2026 Bergen County market update. Those are county numbers. Demarest is a borough of about 5,000 people, and it closes too few sales for a monthly town figure to hold still.
Against that county backdrop, 6 Central Avenue at 120% of asking stands out. The house went from list date to closing in about two months. The final price landed $150,000 above the asking figure, a sign that the market valued that lot and that location well beyond where the listing started.
The same pattern shows up elsewhere in Demarest's late-summer sales. A split-level at 124 Lenox Avenue sold for $1,170,000 on September 23, 2026, and a Colonial at 39 Maple Avenue sold for $1,375,000 on September 1. Original Demarest houses in this range are the entry point into the borough, and in 2026 that entry point drew the crowd.
What a Builder Carries for a Year
The upper end of Central Avenue makes more sense once you see what the builder at number 3 took on before a buyer ever walked through. The borough's record lays out the dates. The building permit was issued May 15, 2025. The roof was finished by August 15, 2025. The certificate of occupancy came May 11, 2026, and the home sold ten days later, on May 21.
That is just under a year from permit to occupancy. The builder carried the land, the construction cost and the market risk for that whole year, and the house was finished and ready to occupy before it changed hands.
Part of what a buyer pays for in a finished Demarest new build is that someone else already lived through that year. Even so, the seller at number 3 accepted $49,000 under asking. At number 7, after a listing that ran from March 6 to a July 3 closing, the price ended about $265,000 under its original ask. A builder who has carried a project for a year has a reason to want the sale finished, and that shows up in the final number.
The Design Questions That Come With a Smaller Lot
Not every rebuild in Demarest sits on a large parcel, and the planning record shows how much design thought goes into fitting a new house among older neighbors. At 52 Edward Street, according to the board's resolution on the project, an LLC applied to remove a 1½-story house and build a two-story home on a 10,000-square-foot lot. The board heard the application on July 1, 2026, and approved it. The project's planner testified that the neighborhood has many lots of that size.
The architect, Stephanie De Carlo Pantale, described the house as a transitional, modern structure. She stepped back both sides of the house so that neighbors would not face large flat walls, and she chose a hip roof over the gables common on that street to reduce the visual impact on the houses next door. At the board's request, the basement bedroom was moved to the rear so that a front window well could be eliminated. The site plan also adds a new driveway, a front walkway and a rear patio.
Choices like these decide how a new house sits on its street, and in Demarest they are worked out in public before construction starts. Walking a finished new build means seeing the outcome of that work, while buying an original house to rebuild means taking it on yourself.
That pipeline is still moving. 25 Meadow St., LLC's application to build a new single-family home appeared on the board's September 2, 2026 agenda. On April 27, 2026, the borough council also introduced Ordinance 1180-26, a replacement of Demarest's zoning chapter, according to the borough's notice of introduction.
Reading the Gap on John Street
29 John Street shows the same arc a few blocks away. The project went through the Joint Planning Board in 2025 as application JPB-25-008. Its file includes plans dated July through October 2025 and a landscape plan dated October 6, 2025. The house came to market October 2, 2026, at an asking price of $3,290,000. NJMLS lists it as new construction on a new foundation: six bedrooms, six full baths, a white stucco facade with ACRE siding accents, and an approval and permit for a pool on a corner lot.
The same listing names its nearby recent sales: the Lenox Avenue split-level at $1,170,000, the Central Avenue ranch at $900,000 and the Maple Avenue Colonial at $1,375,000.
Paying for an original house and its lot in 2026 meant meeting competition, sometimes well above asking, and then either living with the house as it stands or taking on a year or more of design, approvals and construction. Paying a builder who has already done that work put the buyer in a different position, and Central Avenue suggests that at the top of the market, that buyer had more room to talk. Two six-bedroom sales on one street closed at 98.6% and 92.8% of asking, while the ranch across the way closed at 120%.
Bergen County's October 2026 report points the same direction at a larger scale. Inventory was up 15.7% from October 2025, months' supply was up 21.7% to 2.8 months, and closed sales were down 9.2%. More supply gives buyers time, and time matters most on houses priced where fewer buyers can compete.
For buyers looking at original houses, Demarest's older homes deserve the same careful inspection that an underground oil tank question calls for. For sellers of finished homes, how pricing and presentation line up decides whether a listing ends closer to 98% of asking or closer to 93%. More background on the borough is on the Demarest neighborhood page.
If you are deciding between an original Demarest house and a new build, or wondering where your own home falls on that spectrum, Mia Hur can walk you through recent sales street by street, from Central Avenue to John Street, and talk through timing and where your bargaining room actually lies. Let's Connect.