At 4 p.m., the dining room at 25 Highwood Avenue opens for dinner. A short walk away at 6–8 Washington Street, the bagel counter has half an hour left before it closes. For that half hour, both of downtown Tenafly's October arrivals are open at once. The rest of the day belongs to one or the other.
That handoff is new. PopUp Bagels opened on Washington Street on October 9, and Serafina opened on Highwood Avenue in mid-October. Each is its brand's first location in Bergen County. Between them they now cover downtown from 7 in the morning to 10 at night. The bagel shop came together within a few weeks of its announcement. The dinner spot took about two years, and the borough's own paperwork shows why.
Two Sets of Hours That Barely Overlap
The published schedules show how the two businesses divide the day.
| PopUp Bagels | Serafina | |
|---|---|---|
| Address | 6–8 Washington St. | 25 Highwood Ave. |
| Listed hours | 7:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. daily | 4:00 p.m. to 10:00 p.m. daily |
| Format | Whole bagels, torn and dipped into schmears | Sit-down Italian, with reservations |
| Significance | First Bergen County location | First New Jersey location |
Neither one cuts into the other's hours. One covers breakfast and lunch, and the other covers dinner. Between them, a downtown that already had its regulars now has two names that many people know from Manhattan.
The Morning Half Arrived Fast
PopUp Bagels was announced and opened within the same week. NorthJersey.com reported on October 5 that the chain would open at 6–8 Washington St. on October 9. The paper described the Tenafly store as part of a larger push in which PopUp is adding 25 locations across New Jersey. That push started in Westfield in July 2026.
So Tenafly came early in that expansion. The chain's first New Jersey store opened in July. By October it had reached the Northern Valley, and Boozy Burbs confirmed on October 20 that the Washington Street shop was open as the brand's first in Bergen County.
The menu is narrower than at a typical bagel shop. Boozy Burbs describes the bagels as served whole, meant to be ripped apart and dipped into a rotating set of schmears, without slicing or building sandwiches. The Tenafly location page lists the same hours every day, 7:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. That covers the school drop-off hour, the commuter rush, and the weekend errand loop.
The Evening Half Took Two Years
Serafina's route to Highwood Avenue was much slower. Signs for the restaurant first went up at 25 Highwood Avenue in 2024, according to The Bergen County Girl. In January 2025, WhatNow reported, citing the Tenafly Chamber of Commerce, that the restaurant was expected to be ready that spring. Spring came and went. The borough records fill in the rest.
- 2024. Serafina signage appears at 25 Highwood Avenue.
- January 2025. WhatNow reports, citing the Chamber, that Serafina expects to open that spring.
- December 22, 2025. The Tenafly Mayor and Council approve the transfer of a liquor license to Serafina Tenafly, LLC at 25 Highwood Avenue, effective December 9, 2025. The resolution describes the license as having been in pocket status.
- July 13, 2026. The council grants Serafina an outdoor seating permit under Borough Code 4-25.
- Mid-October 2026. The restaurant opens for dinner.
The December resolution put the license transfer on record about ten months before opening night. Seven months after that came the July outdoor seating approval, so the sidewalk plan was approved before the doors opened.
The address has seen several restaurants before this one. WhatNow reported that 25 Highwood Avenue previously housed Sachun House, an Asian fusion restaurant, and Hong Bo Suk. Serafina is the latest in that line, and the first to arrive with a three-decade brand behind it.
What Serafina Brings to Highwood Avenue
The brand began in 1995 as Serafina Fabulous Pizza on 79th Street on Manhattan's Upper East Side. Founders Vittorio Assaf and Fabio Granato have since grown it across three continents, Hoodline reported, citing the company's own history. According to the same report, Serafina had ten Manhattan locations by 2024, along with suburban restaurants in Scarsdale, White Plains, and East Hampton. Before Tenafly, its closest suburban outposts were across the Hudson in Westchester.
The Tenafly menu includes truffle-whipped ricotta, lobster ravioli, and a spaghetti aglio e olio named "Al Pacino." Before opening, Boozy Burbs reported a redesigned interior with velvet seating, warm lighting, and a full bar. The Bergen County Girl described it as a sit-down restaurant, and the restaurant's page takes reservations.
Early diners found the room busy. One OpenTable reviewer who ate there on October 24 wrote of being excited that Serafina had "finally opened its doors." Another described the dining room as "quite full" and "a little noisy." Anyone hoping to walk in on a Friday may want to book ahead.
The Same Summer Permit List
The July 13 resolution that cleared Serafina's outdoor tables covered four other downtown businesses at the same time.
- Serafina, 25 Highwood Ave.
- Café Angelique, 1 Piermont Rd.
- Build Your Yogurt, 6 Washington St.
- Axia Taverna, 18 Piermont Rd.
- Emanu-el Deli, 52 W. Railroad Ave.
Together these addresses outline downtown's outdoor seating for the season. Piermont Road has two entries, Washington Street and Highwood Avenue one each, and West Railroad Avenue one. Every business on the list had a complete application reviewed by the Construction Official before the council signed off.
The list also shows where the new arrivals fit among downtown's existing places to eat, from Café Angelique and Axia Taverna on Piermont Road to Emanu-el Deli on West Railroad Avenue. What changed in October is that both ends of the day now have a brand that has never had a Bergen County address before.
How the Day Divides Now
For someone walking downtown, the change shows up in the schedule. A 7 a.m. stop on Washington Street is now possible before the commute or school run. A dinner reservation on Highwood Avenue is now possible on a weeknight without crossing the bridge. Weekends are covered at both ends too, since both schedules list daily hours.
The two arrivals also show two ways a business can come to downtown Tenafly. PopUp moved quickly as part of a statewide plan, with Tenafly as one of many planned stops. Serafina came more slowly, through a 2024 sign, a missed 2025 target, a December license vote, and a July seating permit. Both reached Tenafly within about a week of each other in October 2026, at addresses a short walk apart.
If you're weighing how close you'd like to live to Washington Street and Highwood Avenue, and which nearby blocks make an easy morning or evening walk, Mia Hur knows these streets from the sidewalk up. Let's Connect.